Home

PuroExpress.Com
The Hole-In-One Cigar Holder!
El Original
Smokeshop Finder
Auction.Smokemag.Com
Magic Matt
Cigar Rights of America
PuroExpress.Com
The Hole-In-One Cigar Holder!
El Original
Smokeshop Finder
Auction.Smokemag.Com
Magic Matt
Cigar Rights of America
PuroExpress.Com
The Hole-In-One Cigar Holder!
El Original
Smokeshop Finder
Auction.Smokemag.Com
Magic Matt


CigarCyclopedia!

 Smoke the Vote!
Fall is upon us once again, and with it, election season and all its grand traditions: shaking hands at commuter hubs, cradling babies for photo ops, and inundating the electorate with rhetoric-filled TV and radio commercials that seem to become increasingly shrill and nasty as that fateful November day approaches. And while the nationwide circus of the Presidential race is still three years away, the noise generated by the local contests is more than enough to drive many of us, regardless of our politics, away from our television set to the porch or patio - and the soothing balm of a quiet, leisurely cigar.

These days, it’s easy to get wrapped up in the politics of smoking - a condition I found to be rampant in my recent visit to Washington D.C for this issue’s Smoke City feature. And while the right to smoke a cigar in peace is an issue worth the time and effort put into it, it should not be so foremost in our minds that we forget what we’re fighting for - namely the sheer pleasure and peace of mind that an hour with our favorite cigar can deliver in these trying times.

SMOKE Cigar Ratings
RatingQuality
0-5.9Poor
6.0-6.9Fair
7.0-7.9Average
8.0-8.5Good
8.6-9.0Very Good
9.1-9.5Excellent
9.6-10.0Superior
Our Cigar Review panelists certainly found pleasures galore in this issue’s selection of cigars, awarding the most uniformly impressive scores we’ve seen in a while, including the highest numerical rating achieved under our new 10-point scoring system.

That distinction went to the Carlos Toraño Signature Collection Perfecto, a Honduran-made figurado that our reviewers gave an unprecedented 9.5. Another figurado, the uniquely shaped Camacho Corojo - sort of an inverted baseball bat where you light the handle end and puff on the business end - impressed tasters across the board, earning a 9.3, Another top scorer, the Edge Torpedo by Rocky Patel (another 9.3) also hails from Honduras.

The bargain-priced American Stogies brand continued its run of excellent ratings in our blind tasting, with the American Stogies Torpedo Maduro earning another 9.3. At a retail price around $3.00, it takes the prize for best value in this issue’s field.

The other cigar to reach the 9.3 pinnacle, was, naturally, a Habano: the Partagas Serie P No. 2 - another sign that dedication to quality cigar making is alive and well in the legendary factories of Cuba. Full results await you on the following pages.

A “welcome aboard” and sincere thanks to our many first-time cigar reviewers, notably Kevin Corblies, Butch Cole, and Eric Morgan, all winners of our Smoke Online “Become a Reviewer” Contest. If you’ve got an educated cigar palate and the words to express it, log on to www.smokemag.com for the chance to add your voice to our roster of panelists.

While you’re at it, don’t forget to make your voice heard at the ballot box this November. Look past the baby-kissing and populist sound bites, and support the candidate you feel is more likely to preserve your personal freedoms as a cigar smoker, or - at the very least- less likely to try to snatch them away.

- Mark Bernardo


Want more? For the full details of each review, including all the panelists views on aesthetics, construction, flavor, and more, subscribe now - or pick up a copy of SMOKE Magazine at a Tobacconist near you!

SAINT LUIS REY Double Corona
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
Altadis USA
Size:
6 1/2 x 48
Filler:
Hon/Nic/Peru
Binder:
Nic
Wrapper:
Costa Rica
Panelist #1 The most consistent-tasting cigar I've had in years! I thoroughly enjoyed it with a matured Talisker.
9.6 SUPERIOR
Panelist #2 This one performed as I expected: good start and fantastic finish. It's perfect for an afternoon break.
9.0 VERY GOOD
Panelist #3 A pleasurable cigar that matches well with Scotch on the rocks. I'd consider price before buying one.
8.5 GOOD
Panelist #4 This one speaks volumes of its creator. Those looking for a sophisticated smoke will be well-rewarded.
9.0 VERY GOOD

PUROS INDIOS Toro Especial
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
Puros Indios Cigars
Size:
6 x 53
Filler:
DR/Nic/Braz
Binder:
Ecu
Wrapper:
Ecu
Panelist #1 An extremely solid smoke, suited for both the novice and the educated palate. This is one for the humidor.
9.4 EXCELLENT
Panelist #2 This wonderful cigar has Puros Indios written all over it. A good choice any time of day, with soft drink or coffee.
8.6 VERY GOOD
Panelist #3 A pleasantly powerful smoke, in need of some age to mellow out the lingering harshness in the finish.
8.1 GOOD
Panelist #4 I would add this brute to my cigar collection in a minute! After a good hour, I wanted it to last even longer!
9.1 EXCELLENT

SAVINELLI NICARAGUA RESERVE Corona
Country:
Nic
Manufacturer:
Savinelli LTD
Size:
5 1/2 x 44
Filler:
Nic
Binder:
Nic
Wrapper:
Nic
Panelist #1 The perfect cigar for someone developing a palate. After a few months in the humidor, they should kick ass.
9.4 EXCELLENT
Panelist #2 This one tastes and performs as good as it looks. A perfect afternoon smoke for those short on time.
9.2 EXCELLENT
Panelist #3 Maybe this one had more nuance than I could grasp. Not a bad cigar, and perhaps less subtle with age.
8.6 VERY GOOD
Panelist #4 Simply put, it is excellent. A perfect companion when you need a hearty smoke and you're pressed for time.
9.5 EXCELLENT

THE EDGE BY ROCKY PATEL Torpedo
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
Indian Tabac Cigar Co.
Size:
6 x 52
Filler:
Hon/Nic
Binder:
Hon
Wrapper:
Hon
Panelist #1 It's strong, it's powerful - I can't get enough! Best with rich, dark coffee, away from cigar-thief friends.
9.8 SUPERIOR
Panelist #2 Consistent across all samples, and perfect with a light-bodied Scotch. I wish you'd sent me a whole box!
9.4 EXCELLENT
Panelist #3 An opportunity to relax after a steak and a Remy Martin XO Cognac and contemplate the world's problems.
9.0 VERY GOOD
Panelist #4 I can definitely see smokers liking this one. An after-six smoke, maybe after a banana pudding dessert.
8.8 VERY GOOD

EXQUISITOS Presidente
Country:
DR
Manufacturer:
Crown David Cigar Co.
Size:
7 x 50
Filler:
DR
Binder:
DR
Wrapper:
Ct/Ecu
Panelist #1 The best of both worlds combined for an enjoyable smoke. A Cuban coffee matches up well with it.
9.1 EXCELLENT
Panelist #2 I was pleasantly surprised by this one. It's a perfect smoke to follow up a late-morning Sunday brunch.
9.0 VERY GOOD
Panelist #3 Don't let its novelty wrapper make you shy away, and make sure you save a long evening to enjoy it!
9.2 EXCELLENT
Panelist #4 Not overly compelling but unique in its flavor and novelty appearance. Overall, a worthwhile 90 minutes.
8.8 VERY GOOD

The El Original

FLOR DE JARDIN Torpedo
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
Flor de Jardin
Size:
6 1/8 x 52
Filler:
Nic
Binder:
Hon
Wrapper:
Ecu
Panelist #1 This is the first cigar I've appreciated more with a Guinness than a fine bourbon. Bring more of these on!
9.6 SUPERIOR
Panelist #2 It's not a powerhouse, but would earn a regular spot in the rotation, even for a maduro man like myself.
9.3 EXCELLENT
Panelist #3 The flavors remain consistent and never overpower. This would be ideal with coffee, or right before dinner.
8.5 GOOD
Panelist #4 Starting out dry and improving by the end, this one reminded me of a Cuban with some young tobacco.
9.0 VERY GOOD

SAN MARTIN Corona No. 1 Churchill
Country:
Peru
Manufacturer:
Tabacalera del Oriente
Size:
6 3/8 x 48
Filler:
Peru
Binder:
Peru
Wrapper:
Peru
Panelist #1 Construction problems detract from an otherwise enjoyable taste. At the right price, this one's worth a try.
8.7 VERY GOOD
Panelist #2 This is a good cigar, but to my palate, the flavors didn't really go anywhere. Others may enjoy it.
8.1 GOOD
Panelist #3 Overall, a plain Jane without much excitement. A good choice for doing yard work or household chores.
8.0 GOOD
Panelist #4 I enjoyed this one's mostly medium-bodied profile. It paired up well with some good rum after dinner.
9.2 EXCELLENT

PUNCH RARE COROJO El Doble
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
General Cigar Co.
Size:
6 x 60
Filler:
DR/Nic/Hon
Binder:
Conn
Wrapper:
Ecu
Panelist #1 A great cigar that matches well with some sangria after a filet mignon dinner. Truly a must-have.
9.0 VERY GOOD
Panelist #2 The ring gauge is a bit too large for comfortable smoking, but the flavors will benefit from some aging.
8.9 VERY GOOD
Panelist #3 A very relaxing smoke that reminds me of a Cuban Sancho Panza. I'd recommend it to almost all palates.
8.7 VERY GOOD
Panelist #4 By the end it was still milder than I expected, but still made a good after-dinner treat with a tawny port.
8.8 VERY GOOD

CUSANO P-1 Robusto
Country:
DR
Manufacturer:
Dom Rey Cigar Ltd.
Size:
5 x 50
Filler:
DR
Binder:
DR
Wrapper:
Conn
Panelist #1 This cigar's superior taste overcomes its so-so construction. Should be a good morning smoke if priced right.
9.2 EXCELLENT
Panelist #2 Overall, a good budget cigar that matched nicely with a California Meritage. Samples are consistent.
8.1 GOOD
Panelist #3 In politics, this cigar would be a moderate: not too strong nor too weak. I'd buy it if it's priced right.
8.3 GOOD
Panelist #4 All things considered, this would be a desirable smoke. It compliments a pint of Guinness exceptionally well.
9.0 VERY GOOD

CABALLEROS Vintage Rothschild
Country:
Hon
Manufacturer:
James Norman Ltd.
Size:
5 x 50
Filler:
DR/Hon/Nic
Binder:
Conn
Wrapper:
Conn
Panelist #1 This was a good smoke. I enjoyed it most as a first cigar of the day with a cup of Haitian blue coffee.
8.7 VERY GOOD
Panelist #2 Some samples burned better than others, but all made me want to try another. That says something...
8.0 GOOD
Panelist #3 This cigar was very good after lunch but I could see novices and pros alike enjoying it any time of day.
8.8 VERY GOOD
Panelist #4 Maybe it was just the right cigar after the right meal, but I found this to be perfect for a midday break.
9.5 EXCELLENT

C.GARS LTD

THE GRIFFIN'S Special XXI Edition
Country:
DR
Manufacturer:
Davidoff of Geneva
Size:
6 x 50
Filler:
DR
Binder:
Mex
Wrapper:
Ecu
Panelist #1 The sleeper of the batch! This pocket-sized smoke has a great payoff. Put the top down and enjoy it!
9.5 EXCELLENT
Panelist #2 This one could be easily overlooked due to its appearance; that would be a shame, as it's very appealing.
8.5 GOOD
Panelist #3 That light shade wrapper hides a robust, decadent filler. With a better roll, these could be a show-stopper.
8.2 GOOD
Panelist #4 A well-balanced, expertly blended cigar with enough complexities that it can be enjoyed any time of day.
9.2 EXCELLENT

CARLOS TORAÑO SIGNATURE COLLECTION Perfecto
Country:
DR
Manufacturer:
Torano Cigar Co.
Size:
5 x 51
Filler:
DR/Nic
Binder:
Conn
Wrapper:
Braz
Panelist #1 Perfect all the way, and a nice match with a 30-year-old single malt. I burnt my fingers on this one!
9.6 SUPERIOR
Panelist #2 About as perfect a smoke as you can buy, this one's a Cadillac in a world of Toyotas. Definite humidor choice.
9.5 EXCELLENT
Panelist #3 All the samples were consistent. This powerful beauty performed like a top-fuel dragster. Pros only, please!
9.2 EXCELLENT
Panelist #4 A most pleasing smoke, though not one for the faint-hearted. I would make these gifts to my best friends.
9.7 SUPERIOR


SMOKE Magazine's Cigar Reviewer's Contest!


Continued on next page...
CURRENT ISSUE
ARCHIVES
SUBSCRIBE
REVIEWS
CIGAR FORUM
SEARCH
CONTEST
SHOPPING

HTML Copyright © 2005 by Keys Technologies and SMOKE Magazine. All rights reserved.