Tricks and Treats... (cont.) Want more? For the full details of each review, including all the panelists views on aesthetics, construction, flavor, and more, subscribe now - or pick up a copy of SMOKE Magazine at a Tobacconist near you! CUABA Generosos Country: Cuba Manufacturer: Habanos S.A. Size: 5 x 43 Filler: Cuba Binder: Cuba Wrapper: Cuba Panelist #1 A bold cigar that had lots of great spicy flavors to suit any palate. And it was short enough to smoke quick. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #2 If this isn’t a Cuban it is at least Cuban seed. The spicy flavors were very distinctive of the region. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 Too sharp for my tastes. I prefer a milder stick. I would love to give another one a try. 8.5 GOOD Panelist #4 Had the finish not been so hot and the flavors at the end not been so muddied this be a no-doubter. 8.6 VERY GOOD BATTLEGROUND MYSTERIOSO Dream Country: Hon Manufacturer: Battleground Cigars Size: 6 3/4 x 50 Filler: DR/Hon Binder: Peru Wrapper: Conn Panelist #1 I would have prefered a slightly richer flavor profile and firmer construction. I would still try them again. 9.1 EXCELLENT Panelist #2 The cigar was a little soft, maybe it could benefit from some more aging to stiffen up the tobaccos a bit. 8.8 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 I found the cigar to have good flavor and heft to it, but the overall experience was a little on the mild side. 9.2 EXCELLENT Panelist #4 You could pair this cigar with almost anything and not go wrong. Just sit back and savor it with your friends. 9.3 EXCELLENT EL TIANTE Churchill Country: Nic Manufacturer: El Tiante Cigars Size: 7 x 50 Filler: Nic/Mex Binder: Mex Wrapper: Nic Panelist #1 A very good smoke as is, but this would be even better if it were aged for a few more months. 8.7 VERY GOOD Panelist #2 This was a decent smoke to have on the patio with a morning cup of coffee. But keep your lighter nearby. 8.6 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 A little too subdued for my tastes, the smoke itself was quite rich and thick. Good for rookies. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 Its size makes it good for a midday smoke break, or a good one to light up after the front nine. 9.0 VERY GOOD HOYO DE TRADICION Epicure Country: Hon Manufacturer: General Cigar Co. Size: 5 1/4 x 50 Filler: DR/Hon Binder: Nic Wrapper: Connecticut Panelist #1 This is an enjoyable cigar from start to finish. I suggest having it after dinner to highlight the flavors. 9.4 EXCELLENT Panelist #2 I tend to like sharper flavors. This cigar though is very well made and perfect for someone’s palate. 9.5 EXCELLENT Panelist #3 I would smoke this again. Perhaps not as my regular cigar, but certainly a nice change of pace smoke. 9.4 EXCELLENT Panelist #4 Great cigar. Burns very evenly and really pops in the beginning. Not a cigar for a novice. 9.5 EXCELLENT LTC Petit Torpedo Country: DR Manufacturer: La Tradicion Cubana Size: 5 x 54 Filler: DR/Nic Binder: DR Wrapper: Ecu Panelist #1 Save this cigar for a special evening, preferably matched up with your favorite whiskey. 9.3 EXCELLENT Panelist #2 I would recommend these to anyone who likes full-bodied smokes. They’re a flavorful kick in the rear. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 This one packs a punch that you may not be ready for. I would not give it to a newcomer. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 This cigar holds its own after a hearty meal, and matches well with an espresso or small-batch bourbon. 9.1 EXCELLENT ROMEO Y JULIETA HABANA RESERVE Robusto Country: Hon Manufacturer: Altadis U.S.A. Size: 5 x 54 Filler: Hon/Nic Binder: Nic Wrapper: Nic Panelist #1 As someone who usually goes for a powerhouse smoke, this cigar was a wonderful change of pace. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #2 These cigars could use some humidor time. I’d give them some age and revisit them in the future. 8.7 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 If you’re looking for strength alone, look elsewhere; if you want a tasty, all-day treat, it’s right here. 9.1 EXCELLENT Panelist #4 An exceptional cigar. Sit back and smoke one after midnight with your best friend to fully appreciate it. 9.3 EXCELLENT CUBA ALIADOS 83RD ANNIVERSARY LIMITED EDITION Short Country: Hon Manufacturer: Puros Indios Size: 4 x 48 Filler: DR/Nic Binder: Ecu Wrapper: Ecu Panelist #1 A nice afternoon smoke with my lunch. I think it would be better if I had a beer or two with me. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #2 I would suggest it to anyone who likes a mild smoke. The price point would be a deciding factor to me. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 I would suggest this cigar to a friend. Probably not a newbie as the start was a little too hot for a novice. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 This is a cigar that’s going right on my ‘buy list.’ I openly suggest it to any level of smoker. 9.4 EXCELLENT DON TOMAS CLASICO Allegro Country: Hon Manufacturer: General Cigar Co. Size: 5 1/2 x 50 Filler: DR/Hon Binder: Hon Wrapper: Mex Panelist #1 A solid smoke that doesn’t overpower. It would go well with an espresso or any other coffee. 9.1 EXCELLENT Panelist #2 A nice cigar to have outside in autumn in the Northeast. It invokes certain thoughts with each draw. 8.8 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 A really good cigar. I hope I can afford to buy a box and if not I hope someone will buy them for me. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 I like my cigars strong, with noticeable flavor and aroma. This had neither. A good smoke for a novice. 8.5 GOOD SAVINELLI SPECIAL SELECTION 2005 Robusto Country: Nic Manufacturer: Savinelli USA Size: 5 x 52 Filler: Nic Binder: Nic Wrapper: Nic Panelist #1 I would suggest this to a new smoker. Someone who needs to be broken in with a light, easy smoke. 9.1 EXCELLENT Panelist #2 Good cigar to have with a nice, cold beer. I’m certain my friends would enjoy it and would suggest it. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #3 Much too mild for me, but perfect for a newbie. The cigar had no aftertaste or bitterness. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 Just a delightful cigar. This is one to recommend to novice smokers ready to move up. 9.2 EXCELLENT TRADER’S RESERVE Churchill Country: DR Manufacturer: Flor de los Reyes Size: 7 x 50 Filler: DR Binder: DR Wrapper: Conn Panelist #1 Not my style, but would suggest to anyone who likes a mild smoke or is just getting into cigars. 9.0 VERY GOOD Panelist #2 I would suggest this cigar to a friend. A good smoke with an adult beverage and a good game on TV. 9.1 EXCELLENT Panelist #3 Not the sort of cigar I normally go for but good just the same, I would buy it if the price were right. 8.9 VERY GOOD Panelist #4 Wish the ending had been better, but a top-notch cigar otherwise. Very strong and yet subtle at once. 8.9 VERY GOOD SMOKE - Fall, 2007 CURRENT ISSUE ARCHIVES SUBSCRIBE REVIEWS CIGAR FORUM SEARCH CONTEST SHOPPING HTML Copyright © 2007 by Keys Technologies and SMOKE Magazine. All rights reserved.